Buffalo Exchange
Closed
About Buffalo Exchange
Buffalo Exchange is a retail store in New York City that specializes in buying and selling secondhand clothing and accessories. It's a great place to refresh your wardrobe while also giving pre-loved items a new home.
The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, with a diverse selection of clothing racks that appeal to a wide range of styles. Customers can easily sell their items without an appointment, making the experience both convenient and casual.
Located in Midtown, Buffalo Exchange is easily accessible for shoppers in the fashion district. Its proximity to public transportation makes it a convenient stop for those exploring the area.
Editor's Review
Buffalo Exchange has carved out a unique spot in New York's bustling thrift scene since 1992. This family-owned business attracts a diverse crowd, with many customers drawn in by its commitment to sustainable fashion and the thrill of finding hidden gems. Many reviewers appreciate the ease of selling, noting that 'selling was very easy' as Dalilah Rose put it, after a straightforward process that requires no appointment. However, some customers have expressed frustration with the store's buying criteria. Tonnette Alcide's experience highlights a common complaint: the seeming inconsistency in what the store accepts, as she was turned away despite offering unworn, high-quality shoes. It seems you might need to strike the right balance between current trends and vintage vibes.
Overall, Buffalo Exchange stands out for its friendly staff and a well-curated selection, but potential sellers should be aware of the varying standards and pricing that can lead to disappointment. For many, this can be a hit-or-miss experience when it comes to selling items.
What We Like
- Friendly and welcoming staff
- Easy process for selling items
- Diverse selection of unique clothing and accessories
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent buying criteria can frustrate sellers
- Some items can be priced higher than expected
What Customers Are Saying
“Selling was very easy. I scanned the QR and filled out the simple questions.”
— Dalilah Rose
“I wasted an entire hour of my life... only to be told no on every single pair of brand-new shoes...”
— Tonnette Alcide
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Lots of racks and selection.”
“Thought prices were pretty high.”
“The girl with blonde hair was very nice.”
“Selling was very easy.”
Insider Tips
Timing is important for best selection.
Check for sales on items.
Bring items in excellent condition for better offers.
Bin Stores & Amazon Return Stores Details
What to Expect
- Expect a lively and welcoming shopping experience with staff ready to assist you.
- You'll find a wide range of clothing options, from vintage pieces to trendy fashion staples.
- Prices can vary, but many customers find good deals on unique items.
Business Highlights
- ✓Family owned since 1992
- ✓Sell your clothing and accessories anytime
- ✓No appointment required to sell
- ✓Chance to win a $500 gift card
- ✓Limited-edition pop-up shop events
Google Reviews
I came here to sell clothing I no longer wanted. First time and Selling was very easy. I scanned the QR and filled out the simple questions. I waited about 25 mins. The girl with blonde hair was very nice and welcoming. She explained the process and ...
You have to be timing things right The selections are good since its in midtown near fashion and textile area
First time in buffalo exchange in a while so I’m sure things have changed. Thought prices were pretty high, but they still have some items on sail. Lots of racks and selection. Staff was very nice I did find a vintage wool hat for $12 so I feel that...
I ain't ever selling here again. I brought in 3 pairs of sneakers (I actually just wanted to trade for a pair that was $90 and have some credit left over.) One was a pair of Oakley x Brain Dead, essentially brand new, a pair of Nike Shox also like n...
I wasted an entire hour of my life at Brooklyn Exchange only to be told no on every single pair of brand-new shoes I brought in — shoes that were clean, unworn, modern, and in excellent condition. The explanation? Suddenly everything had to be “vinta...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're selling items, try to arrive early to secure your spot on the waitlist.
Timing is important; visiting during off-peak hours can lead to a quicker selling experience.
Consider checking out nearby cafes or shops to explore while you wait for your turn to sell.
Hours
- monday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- tuesday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- wednesday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- thursday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- friday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- saturday11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- sunday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM