Mystery Bins
Open Now
About Mystery Bins
Mystery Bins is a unique shopping destination in West Nyack, NY, offering a variety of products including clothing, home goods, furniture, and shoes. Customers can explore bins filled with unexpected treasures, ranging from everyday items to quirky finds.
The atmosphere inside Mystery Bins can feel a bit chaotic, but that's part of the thrill. Shoppers often describe it as a treasure hunt, where you never know what you'll find, making each visit an adventure.
Conveniently located in West Nyack, Mystery Bins is easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. Ample parking is available, making it a hassle-free stop for anyone looking to uncover great deals.
Editor's Review
Mystery Bins in West Nyack, NY, holds a rating of 4.2 out of 5, reflecting the mixed experiences of its patrons. Despite some customers finding a treasure trove of deals, others express frustration over price inconsistencies. As Justin Delossantos remarked, 'They had a fridge here I just bought new but for cheap!!!!' Yet, contrary to popular belief, not everyone leaves satisfied. Edward Polanco's experience paints a different picture: 'They change prices without notice,' highlighting a recurring complaint about sudden price hikes.
The store is praised for its variety, with Tushar Sonwane noting, 'The variety and quality of products in bins are unmatched.' This sentiment suggests that for those willing to dig through, the potential rewards can be significant. However, the chaotic pricing model remains a sore point. Local Guide lamented, 'They changed that Friday only to $15 day. Not cool. Waste of my time.'
Overall, Mystery Bins attracts bargain hunters ready for a unique adventure but may deter those who prefer a straightforward shopping experience.
What We Like
- Wide variety of products available
- Exceptional customer service
- Potential for great deals
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent pricing practices
- Occasional confusion over product quality
What Customers Are Saying
“They had a fridge here I just bought new but for cheap!!!!”
— Justin Delossantos
“The variety and quality of products in bins are unmatched.”
— Tushar Sonwane
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Found so many random things here.”
“Fridays used to be $1... Now it’s $15.”
“Exceptional customer service.”
“I was very scared during my entire time there.”
Insider Tips
Use gloves while digging through bins.
Check for price changes before your visit.
Visit on Fridays for potential deals, but verify pricing.
What to Expect
- Expect a treasure hunt atmosphere where you'll sift through various bins to find unique items.
- Product selection changes frequently, so there's always something new to discover with each visit.
- Prices are generally low, making it a great place for bargain hunters looking for steals.
Google Reviews
Not my type of store but found so many random things here. Good for people looking for a steal. Looks like they have different stuff all the time. They had a fridge here they I just bought new but for cheap!!!! I recommend using gloves.
If you’re looking for the best bin store in town, look no further! This place truly stands out. The variety and quality of products in bins are unmatched, and whether you’re shopping for something simple or specific, they’ve got it all. What really s...
STAY AWAY! THEY CHANGE PRICES WITHOUT NOTICE. This place has gone completely downhill and it's honestly disturbing. Fridays used to be $1—a fun way to dig through some junk and maybe find a deal. Now it’s $15 for the same exact garbage that used to ...
Drove 1.5 hrs each way to go on 4/18 for $1 day. Unbeknownst to me, they changed that Friday only to $15 day. Not cool. Waste of my time. They said it was for the holiday weekend. So they can cash in on more money? Usually, places put stuff on sale f...
lowkey i was very scared during my entire time there like it was giving backrooms level. tbh i couldve gone the rest of my life without seeing some of the things i saw in the bins. also mysterious music kept playing and it was so cold i felt my tip f...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
Come with an open mind and be prepared to explore, as the store's layout can be a bit overwhelming at first.
Try to visit during the week, as weekends can get crowded and the best items may be picked over.
Check nearby options for dining or coffee to enjoy before or after your shopping experience.
Hours
- monday10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- tuesday10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- wednesday10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- thursday10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
- friday10:00 AM - 9:30 PM
- saturday10:00 AM - 9:30 PM
- sunday11:00 AM - 7:00 PM